When you’re searching for an online dating site, and are ready to choose the perfect one, you’re bound to encounter many reviews and lists of the top dating site options.
Across the web on many of those lists, you’ll most likely see Match.com and eHarmony, and begin to ask yourself, “Is Match or eHarmony better?”
Since you're ultimately the one who has to make the final decision between the two, understanding what you want is important, but we're here to help make the decision easier for you.
From member demographics, pricing, rates of success, and dating sites process for matching, below you'll find all of the information you need to determine if eHarmony or Match is the right site for you.
We’ve matched these two dating site juggernauts head to head to see who comes out victorious! Without further ado we bring to you....
eHarmony vs Match.com: Overall Ratings
- eHarmony vs Match.com: Overall Ratings
- eHarmony or Match: Cost Comparison
- Who Wins the Price Battle?
- Match.com vs eHarmony: User Base
- Match Put Up a Fight, But eHarmony Wins
- eHarmony versus Match: Matching Comparison
- Our Choice: eHarmony's Sophisticated Matching
- eHarmony vs. Match: Success Rate Comparison
- Our Choice For Success Rates: Match
- So, Who Is The Ultimate Winner?
We've spent hundreds of hours reviewing, testing, reading, writing and recommending online dating sites to our subscribers, readers, family, friends, and acquaintances. Essentially, we eat, sleep, breath, and live online dating.
Over the many years we’ve spent covering dating online, eHarmony and Match have been at the forefront of the most popular dating websites, and we've become very familiar with both.
If you feel like you have trouble navigating online dating and deciding which site is best for you, we understand. Rest assured, however, our review will help you determine which site is better for you!
They do have their differences, which we’ve broken down in this comparison. Let's get started shall we?
eHarmony: 4.6 / 5.0
When comparing Match and eHarmony, think about vanilla and chocolate ice cream. Your individual tastes and preferences would help you determine which site is a better fit for you. But both have their good qualities.
eHarmony takes the reigns with their matchmaking approach by using a 29 dimension personality assessment to suggest compatible matches. Meaning you let eHarmony’s matching system do most of the work to help you find dates.
We gave eHarmony a 4.6 out of 5 star rating because some people like to search for their own dates, and you can’t do that on eHarmony.
This lack of an important feature to some isn’t such a big deal to others, however. Many people find that eHarmony is the perfect site for them and like that the whole matchmaking process is taken care of for them.
eHarmony has over 35 million members, the highest of any relationship driven dating sites, which gives it an edge over Match and other sites.
Please note: You’ll want to visit Compatible Partners, eHarmony’s sister website, if you’re gay or lesbian. So consider this when making your final decision.
25 - 45
Number of Members
For Singles Seeking
Dates & Relationships
Match: 4.1 / 5.0
The combination of affordability and features give Match an overall score of 4.1 out of 5 stars. It’s one of the first dating sites established back in 1995 and has around 29 million members and 14 million visitors per month.
You can try out their standard membership for free and subscribe to their paid membership very affordably.
Their Reverse Matching system is the best features of their online platform, with a handful of additional features that make your dating experience effortless.
Perhaps the most important fact about Match, is it’s success rate. This site is responsible for more relationships than any other dating site.
Match rates #2 in popularity amongst singles seeking relationships, only to eHarmony. You most likely know a few people who have tried using the site, and even people who have successfully found a great relationship.
Being the first site in online dating, Match is a trailblazer and will be here to stay for a long time. However it is important to note, that Match has decreased in quality over the years and has many more complaints than before. This is one of the things that has allowed eHarmony to take the #1 spot.
20 - 45
Number of Members
For Singles Seeking
Dates & Relationships
eHarmony or Match: Cost Comparison
The features and benefits of a dating site is just one thing to consider, but if the cost is outside your budget, then it doesn’t matter how many bells and whistles the site has. Both of these dating sites have some of the most affordable membership prices. Here’s what you should expect to pay:
eHarmony: From $0 to $69.90 Memberships
eHarmony is an affordable dating site with a free lifetime membership. With a free account, you can take the 29 dimension personality questionnaire, get the results of that compatibility assessment, browse profiles, and even have high quality matches delivered to you.
The free account is great, but you can’t communicate with your matches (except for few times per year around holiday time) unless you get a paid membership.
Instead of waiting, you can register for the full membership subscription which gives you access to the many features eHarmony has to offer, such as Secure Call and Guide Communication.
The highest membership cost on the site right now is $69.90 per month for six full months. The lowest is $35.90 per month for 24 full months. But with the deals we have, you can save 40% on any new membership.
Match: From $0 to $61.99 Memberships
Whether you want a totally free online dating account or a paid subscription with many features and benefits, Match has both options.
The website’s free membership subscription doesn’t ever expire (which is why the 30 million members is misleading, because non active members can still have active accounts).
With the free account, you can complete your personal profile, add multiple pictures, browse other member profiles, and receive messages and matches on a daily basis. The only thing you won’t be able to do is send messages, unless you have a paid membership.
The the free 3 day trial account is designed for people to experience Match before committing to the paid membership. You can test everything to determine if Match is the right site for you.
If you are not on the fence about the paid subscription then you can sign up right away. You can save a considerable amount using our special links below to get anywhere from 38 - 66% off memberships.
Who Wins the Price Battle?
eHarmony and Match.com are both competitively priced. If you are looking at face value of price, then Match wins based on it's lower monthly price (about $6-10 depending on which membership level you get).
However, the amount of value that you get from eHarmony far exceeds the small discount with Match. You get a more sophisticated matching system that matches you with people from your 29 dimension personality test.
There are also many more active members and available singles from city to city than Match. Plus, the customer service is much more responsive and helpful.
So even being slightly higher is cost, eHarmony wins this round. Remember the saying when considering cost: "Price is what you pay, value is what you get."
Match.com vs eHarmony: User Base
While it may seem obvious, you want to choose a dating site where you’re around other people you’re going to find attractive, desire dating, and even get into a serious relationship or marriage, if that’s the ultimate goal you have.
The amount of users on a site doesn’t matter as much as the quality of members that are your type AND how active the members on the site are. Read further to find out about Match and eHarmony’s user breakdown.
Match: 29 Million Straight & Gay Members from 30 Countries
Match.com's user base is currently around 29 million and still rising into 2020. As one of the largest dating websites in the world, you can find users in more than 30 countries with a wide range of demographics including: ethnicity, age, and sexual orientation.
You can select each trait and characteristic that are most important for you during the sign up process so that you can easily sort through users using your chosen filters.
eHarmony: 35 Million Members from Over 130 Countries
eHarmony beats out Match in this section with over 35 million users in 140 countries. The drawback to eHarmony is that they only cater to heterosexual members.
Gay and lesbians users will have to use Compatible Partners if they want to take advantage of eHarmony’s unique matching system.
If you are Christian, then eHarmony may be a better fit for you also, considering the site was founded by a Christian and many members practice the Christian faith.
Match Put Up a Fight, But eHarmony Wins
If you are a LGBTQ member, then Match wins this due to it's diversity in membership and the fact that eHarmony has a totally different website for LGBTQ.
However, if you are not LGBTQ, eHarmony wins this battle of user base. eHarmony has a higher number of members and they are much more active than Match members.
The choice is yours, but we give the very slight edge to eHarmony because of the higher activity of members.
eHarmony versus Match: Matching Comparison
So how does Match and eHarmony’s matchmaking process work to find people you’d be interested in and compatible with? Both of these websites have excellent matching systems and are consistently improving their processes to provide the highest quality experience for users.
eHarmony: 29 Dimension Compatibility Matching System Finds Matches for You
eHarmony is known for many things within the dating world, but one of their most unique features is their 29 dimensions of Compatibility Matching System.
Dr. Neil Warren, a psychologist and Christian professor, founded eHarmony based upon this personality assessment. It consists of 140+ questions (the more you answer the higher quality matches you’ll receive) and takes about 45 minutes to complete.
The site then cross examines your answers (like beliefs, faith, family, values) with other members of eHarmony to provide the most compatible matches for you. This sophisticated matching system is what allows this site to be so successful in helping you find a true match.
Match: Receive Daily Matches + Search On Your Own
Match provides users two different ways to discover potential matches: Use search filters based on your personal criteria and preferences and check your inbox for the daily matches sent directly by Match.
You can also utilize the Reverse Matching system, where you have the ability to check out users who are seeking the same qualities and characteristics you have.
Match states this very well: “No matter how the member fits into your preferred qualities, you can know that you fit into their preferred qualities well.”
One of the top benefits that Match offers, which differentiates them from other dating sites, is their 6 month guarantee.
If within six months you don’t find a real match (and no, not simply someone Match recommended that you didn’t like), you will get another six months at no charge. That’s right. Six full months for free.
Our Choice: eHarmony's Sophisticated Matching
Although Match has multiple ways to receive matches, eHarmony’s sophisticated compatibility matching system is so good that we have to give this round to them.
eHarmony vs. Match: Success Rate Comparison
The purpose of dating online is to quickly and efficiently find high quality people to go out on dates with in real life.
You might want to consider whether or not you’re wasting your valuable time if you have spent months or years browsing through online profiles and sending messages with the members, yet you have not been out on real dates.
Both of these dating sites have such high success rates that you’re bound to find someone compatible if you stick with it. Below are the success rates of each site.
eHarmony: 4% of Marriages in the U.S. Originate Here
Within just 20 years of existence, eHarmony has become responsible for 4% of United States marriages. People on this dating site don’t just get married, they stay married.
The divorce rates on eHarmony are just around 3.93%, which is over 46% less than the 50% national average! Nearly 600 people are married daily because of having met on eHarmony.
Match.com: Most Connections Out of All Dating Websites
Match has been around since 1995, and within the last 25 years have been responsible for creating millions of real dates, billions of member connections, and countless relationships and marriages.
Ready to start a family? Match has even been responsible for 1 Million babies from people who met on this dating site years ago.
When you combine their longevity and matching system that brings so much success, it’s hard to ignore Match as one of the top dating sites around.
Our Choice For Success Rates: Match
Because each dating site has been so successful, it was hard to choose a winner. With 5 more years under their belt, Match has been able to accumulate a higher quantity of success reports. Due to that reason, we give the slight edge to Match.
So, Who Is The Ultimate Winner?
Our conclusion of the “battle of the best” leaves Match winning one round, and eHarmony winning three rounds. Match is slightly better for LGBTQ members, but other than that, eHarmony takes the cake.
Take eHarmony's free 29 dimension personality test by clicking this special link, and if you decide to join after, you'll receive 40% off membership.