Best American Dating Sites Reviewed (October 2019)

You want to find a relationship, companionship, or anything in between. Online dating is likely something you've considered, but you might have some skepticism about it.

It might seem like it's too hard to get to know someone via this process or the sites aren't trustworthy.

While it's true that online dating takes work, and not all sites are created equal, the positive aspects of this experience have helped to forge many lasting relationships.

If you have even a moderately-wide social network, you should know several couples who met through online dating.

The best online dating sites also have great paid membership options. They give you plenty of ways to find a potential partner, and they make it easy to navigate their websites. If you have any issues, they'll be able to help you resolve them in a very transparent manner.

Some sites are specialized, which helps anyone who is looking for something particular in their partner or who has specific needs they want to be met.

These sites can be used by pretty much anyone. They've all become quite popular for various reasons. This guide will help you to determine which of these sites is right for you.

Our Rating

Benefits

Today's Deal

  • Sophisticated Matching
  • Strong Profile Verification
  • Ideal for Professionals

Read Full Review

  • Easy Sign-Up
  • Secure Messaging
  • Post Lots of Photos

Read Full Review

  • Multiple Matching Tools
  • Strong Customer Service
  • Sophisticated Matching System

Read Full Review

  • Detailed Profile Information
  • Compatibility Test
  • Serious Relationships & Marital Focus

Read Full Review

  • Great Casual Encounters
  • Adventurous Couples Fun

Read Full Review

1. Elite Singles

With a name like Elite Singles, you would hope that you're getting the cream of the crop for online dating candidates.

Well, you know that you're a catch, right? There are also all kinds of intriguing people you can find on here. The site also puts quite a lot of emphasis on ensuring authenticity among users.

Instead of letting profiles flow through without any guarantee about their authenticity, the team behind Elite Singles goes through every profile to make sure it's legitimate.

This way, you can explore the site without feeling like you're about to be duped by phony profiles. They also get rid of defunct profiles and apparent jokes.

You can find suitable matches on this site based on the sophistication of their questionnaire. Be sure to answer these as honestly as possible, as you don't want to be matched with anyone who you can't click with.

They take a psychological approach to matching, which allows matches to be made through meaningful considerations, not shallow ones.

If you want to get any real mileage out of EliteSingles, you'll need to sign up for a paid membership. This is the only way to be able to see pictures of your matches and exchange messages with them.

You can purchase memberships for periods of three, six, and 12 months. Be advised that these renew automatically at the end of each cycle.

EliteSingles takes its name very seriously. They want to give their users a sense of trustworthiness in their service.

This is likely why they've been able to provide their users with so much satisfaction. For a first-rate online dating experience, consider joining EliteSingles.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

35+

Number of Members

15 Million

Sign Up
Time

35 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Long-Term Commitment

PROS

  • check
    Sophisticated Matching
  • check
    Strong Profile Verification
  • check
    Ideal for Professionals

CONS

  • check
    Limited Without Paid Membership
  • check
    Longer Profile Setup

2. Match


One of the most famous dating sites for clients of any race, Match.com has secured a reputation for helping clients fall in love.

After more than 20 years in business, Match continues to be part of linking singles together. If you're looking for a place to start on your online dating journey, Match is an excellent choice.

Users can use Match.com to find others based on various preferences, such as how old they are, their gender, and anything else they consider important.

They also cater to different needs in terms of sexual orientation. With a large user base of more than 8 million premium members, Match.com has something for everyone, including black singles.

It's quite easy to get used to Match.com. Starting a profile is very straightforward.

You can include as many as 26 photos. Filling out your profile with as much information as you can is very important, as it will help you to reach more people.

You should also be searching around for profiles of others that catch your attention.

Upon finding someone intriguing, you can start messaging with them.

You don't have to worry about your personal information getting out, as Match.com makes sure to keep all of that secure.

The ease of navigation and friendly design are just a couple of reasons why Match.com has been such a big deal.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

35+

Number of Members

28 Million

Sign Up
Time

25 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Easy Sign-Up
  • check
    Secure Messaging
  • check
    Ability to Post Multiple Photos

CONS

  • check
    Number of Matches Vary By Location
  • check
    Higher Cost

3. Zoosk


Zoosk's name isn't one that immediately reveals itself as being a dating site. However, this unconventionally named site has become known as an excellent place to start a relationship.

Like Match.com and EliteSingles, Zoosk is all about creating bonds through precise matching. You can use all sorts of features to help you find that special someone.

Their sophisticated "Search" feature allows you to easily look around the site for someone who strikes your fancy. You can also use "Online Now" to find out who's free to talk at the present moment.

Those who want to go through a lot of matches at once will want to use "Carousel." This is similar to the swiping features of other online dating services.

Other features include SmartPick, which helps to give you the most nuanced matches, while "Super Send" acts as an email blast for reaching out to different matches.

If you can't find the perfect match right away on Zoosk, there are a myriad of other things to try.

Choosing to upgrade to a paid membership can make your Zoosk experience even more rewarding. The Premium Messaging feature lets you exchange messages with users, regardless of whether or not they have a subscription.

The Hide, Seek and Sneak features let you browse anonymously and give you more control over who sees your profile.

Zoosk gives users quite a lot in its basic form, but the paid membership features are much worthwhile.

To better your chances of success, it's hugely beneficial to use these features. Put yourself out there and see how much your efforts pay off.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

25 - 45

Number of Members

35 Million

Sign Up
Time

15 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Multiple Matching Tools
  • check
    Strong Customer Service
  • check
    Sophisticated Matching System

CONS

  • check
    Activation Fee
  • check
    Limited Search Options

4. eHarmony


eHarmony is one of the most important sites in the history of online dating. Their focus on marriage helped to show that online dating wasn't just limited to hookups or brief relationships.

Members who use eHarmony do so because they believe strongly in their ability to find someone right for them for life. The steady rate of marriages that have started with eHarmony gives credence to their site's focus.

The longstanding reputation of eHarmony means that you should be able to find plenty of people to talk with.

However, before you reach that point, you'll need to fill out the personality tests and answer the questions provided. This will let the site know what sort of matches are ideal for you. Take your time with this, and take a break if necessary.

While messaging is available for all members, you need to purchase a premium membership if you want to craft messages yourself.

Additionally, premium membership also lets you get in touch with more people instead of being limited to matches that the site has designed for you.

On profiles, you can determine how well suited a match is for you based on "compatibility." This is a reflection of the answers you and your potential match had given when you started your respective profiles.

Keep the compatibility in mind, but don't let it be the only thing you consider.

If you're still dreaming of finding the perfect someone, eHarmony is here to help make your dream come true. Put as much into your profile as possible, and keep as optimistic as you can.

So many others have been able to find their beloved spouse through this site. Why not you?

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

30+

Number of Members

18 Million

Sign Up
Time

15 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Marital Focus
  • check
    Detailed Profile Information
  • check
    Compatibility  Test

CONS

  • check
    Not for Casual Dating
  • check
    Limited Messaging Options Without Paid Membership

5. BeNaughty

BeNaughty is a long way from eHarmony or Match.com. It's based on all kinds of experiences, including hookups and group encounters. If you're looking for something lasting, look elsewhere.

However, if you're looking to have some fun or to spice up a current relationship by bringing others into the fold, this could be the right online dating site for you.

BeNaughty has a gender breakdown that is majority female. However, people of different genders and orientations can find something through BeNaughty.

Signing up is very quick, and you can include as much as you deem necessary. You need to make sure that you have a good photo which doesn't go against any of their guidelines.

You need to purchase a premium membership if you want to see beyond profile pictures. You can reach out to users through direct messaging or through the chatroom. Messaging is provided at no cost for female members.

Even though BeNaughty might have a more casual design that other sites, you need to maintain absolute respect for all members you reach out to.

A casual encounter might turn into something more permanent. But it's best to focus on just having fun and not worrying too much.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

25+

Number of Members

500,000

Sign Up
Time

15 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Hookups & Casual Encounters

PROS

  • check
    Great Casual Encounters
  • check
    Adventurous Fun for Couples
  • check
    Strong Profile Verification

CONS

  • check
    Not for Casual Relationships
  • check
    Paid Version Required For Men To Send Messages

Editors Conclusion

All of these sites have different advantages and disadvantages. However, they each cover different needs for different people.

You can browse each of these sites and figure out fairly quickly if a website is right for you. Make a list of dating site preferences and compare it to this list to see which one is best for you.

Sometimes, you might find yourself debating between two sites. There's nothing wrong with signing up for more than one site at a time.

If you have the financial means and time to do so, you can figure out more thoroughly which site is best for you.

However, if you're looking for which one we'd recommend the most, we would have to say
Elite Singles. The site is excellent for people who are looking for dating and/or marriage. 

You can also make a profile in a reasonable amount of time while also giving visitors plenty of insights about you.

Give online dating a shot if you're sick of being single. The only way you can find love is by putting yourself out there, and online dating allows you to do this in the easiest possible way.

Stay diligent with updating your profile and reaching out to matches.

Click here to Join Elite Singles.