Best Catholic Dating Sites Reviewed (October 2019)

Being Catholic isn't just about going to church every Sunday or even participating in confession every so often. It's about living your faith to the best of your abilities and adhering to Catholic doctrine.

The Catholic Church recognizes the importance of love, as evidenced by Holy Matrimony being one of the seven sacraments. But how do you find someone to wed?

Thanks to dating sites, people have been able to have much higher chances at love. You can create detailed profiles that break down exactly who you are and what you're looking for. Potential partners can reach out to you, and before you know it, you can be planning your first date.

This is very important for Catholics, as it can be frustrating to find someone who's not only agreeable in terms of personality, but also in terms of religion.

Finding a partner who's devotion matches yours can be very important. You shouldn't need to be shy about why your faith is so critical to your life.

To help you with your search, we've made a list of the Best Catholic Dating Sites. These are all great sites for anyone looking for Catholic love, and all have excellent premium account options. We hope this list helps you make an excellent decision.

Our Rating

Benefits

Today's Deal

  • Lots of Users
  • Can Search For Catholics
  • For Committed Relationships
  • Faith-Based Origins
  • Large User Base
  • Strong Personality Assessments

Read Full Review

  • Strong Personality Test
  • High-End Users
  • Good Gender Split

Read Full Review

  • Catholic Emphasis
  • Strong Privacy
  • In-Depth Compatibility Assessment

Read Full Review

  • Catholic Focus
  • Active Member Forum
  • Free 6 Months If You Don't Find Match*
  • Faith-Based Founders
  • "Prayer" Feature
  • Informative Profiles

Read Full Review

1. Match

People who've never tried online dating know about Match.com. This website has been bringing people together for more than twenty years, and an excellent record of marriages shows that they're not just about giving people flings. Match is for people who are serious about finding a love that truly lasts.

Signing up isn't difficult. You'll need to provide personal information, such as your date of birth and location. Then, you can start to make your profile, including a brief "About Me" paragraph.

You can include as many as 26 photos. You can also specify your religion and what you want your potential partner's faith to be, to make finding other Catholics easier.

When you reach out to matches, ask them to elaborate about any part of their Catholic beliefs that might need clarifying.

You may come across people who are new to the faith, but this shouldn't deter you. In fact, willing to give them a chance could lead to a solid foundation in building your relationship together.

Match.com requires you to have a paid account to send messages. You can buy these on a one, three, six, and 12-month basis.

It's a perfect place for Catholics who are curious about online dating, as the design, large number of users, and emphasis on genuine relationships, have given it such a great reputation.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

35+

Number of Members

28 Million

Sign Up
Time

25 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Lots of Users
  • check
    Can Search For Catholics
  • check
    For Committed Relationships

CONS

  • check
    Short "About Me" Section

2. eHarmony

eHarmony has been a critical site in the world of online dating because it's helped to show that online dating isn't just about casual relationships.

eHarmony was started by a Christian psychologist who wanted to show the value of matching people in a meaningful way. The result has been a massive number of marriages; all started through eHarmony.

Catholics singles like you can find a lot to love about eHarmony. When you make your profile, you'll have to take some time to fill out the personality test and various questionnaires. This is to help them determine who the best matches are for you.

Once you've gotten your profile made and have signed up for a paid account, you can start reaching out to matches. You'll quickly see just how serious people take their time on this site.

You need to make sure your profile and your messages demonstrate your intentions. If you're ready for a serious commitment, eHarmony is the place for you.

eHarmony isn't specifically geared towards Catholics, but it's faith-based origins and emphasis on lasting unions makes it a natural choice for Catholic singles.

When you sign up, you can quickly find yourself on the way to an honest connection. It's a gift to give to yourself and your new partner.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

30+

Number of Members

1 Million

Sign Up
Time

15 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Faith-Based Origins
  • check
    Large Membership Base
  • check
    Strong Personality Assessments

CONS

  • check
    Long Sign Up Process
  • check
    No Chat Room

3. Elite Singles

Elite Singles has become one of the most famous dating sites for how it helps singles to find people that are impressive and right for them.

This website is primarily frequented by people who are generally older and have college degrees. When you combine that with a strong adhering to the Catholic faith, you can see why Elite Singles is such a good dating site.

When you sign up for Elite Singles, you'll need to fill out a personality test. This is used by the site to help determine who you are and who the best matches are for you.

They use 29 distinct qualities to help figure this out. You'll need to reserve about 20 minutes for filling out this test. Make sure you do it with total attention and honesty.

You'll need to have a paid account if you want to send and receive messages on ​Elite Singles You can also show potential matches that you're interested in them by sending a "wink" at no charge. There's a relatively equal gender split on this site, although the majority of users are male.

Before you can find anyone to love you, you need to have an innate sense of love for yourself. Elite Singles is great for Catholic singles to remember that they are worthy of love, both from others and themselves.

Make yourself a profileand reach out to other elites.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

35+

Number of Members

15 Million

Sign Up
Time

35 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Long-Term Commitment

PROS

  • check
    Strong Personality Test
  • check
    High-End User Base
  • check
    Good Gender Split

CONS

  • check
    Mixed Reviews For Mobile App
  • check
    Longer to Create A Profile

4. Catholic Singles

Knowing that there's a site called "Catholic Singles" can be very reassuring for Catholics who are looking for love.

It will hopefully please you even further to know that this site is an excellent choice for people who want to find someone who values them and their faith.

You can fill out your profile as much as you like, but it's in your best interest to include as much information as possible.

There are also questions about things like your lifestyle and your exact connection with your faith. Catholic Singles is for people who serious about their devotion.

Paid members have the privilege of being able to use the messaging feature. Another useful feature is that you can keep information about when you were last online private.

There's also a "compatibility test" that helps you see how good of a match you and others are.

Catholic Singles is an excellent dating site for Catholics who want to find the right Catholic for them. You can focus on faith and not have any fear of being alienated from potential matches.

With Catholic Singles, you can wear your Catholic faith as an absolute badge of honor. 

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

25+

Number of Members

2 Million

Sign Up
Time

20 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Catholic Emphasis
  • check
    Strong Privacy
  • check
    In-Depth Compatibility Assessment

CONS

  • check
    Anyone Can View Photos
  • check
    Messaging Only For Paid Users

5. Catholic Match

Catholics have it pretty good in the online dating, with Catholic Match being another example of an excellent online dating site geared towards Catholics.

This site is the biggest dating site for Catholics, and its global membership of more than one million people has helped to show that Catholics are a dating demographic that have earned recognition.

Signing up for Catholic Match is easy, and you're able to sign up via Facebook. There will be information you're required to fill out when you fill out your profile. They'll also give you a username based on your name and what number user you are.

Once you've finished your profile, you can reach out to other members. You can only send messages as a paid user, and you can only read messages without a paid account for up to 10 days. Should you not find a match within your first six months, you can get six more months free.

Catholic Match cares about its users and helping them to find the best match possible. This is a site meant not just for Catholic singles, but for Catholic singles who know they have something unusual to offer and want to share it with others.

It's a beautiful experience to know there is someone out there for you and finding them.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

25+

Number of Members

1.5 Million

Sign Up
Time

25 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Long-Term Commitment

PROS

  • check
    Catholic Focus
  • check
    Active Member Forum
  • check
    Free 6 Months If You Don't Find Match*

CONS

  • check
    Long Sign-Up Process
  • check
    Can't Choose Username

6. Christian Cafe

Christian Cafe is another excellent choice for those who are wanting a faith-based dating site. This site might not be aimed at exclusively Catholics, but you're likely to find plenty of Catholics users among the site.

Millions of people have used Christian Cafe as a means of finding a relationship with someone devoted to them and God.

Signing up for Christian Cafe involves giving simple information, such as your location and date of birth. You can also give a username that you'd like to use.

In order to exchange messages and use features like "wink," you need to have a premium account. Your matches can be seen by using "QuickMatch."

You only get up to three photos for your profile on Christian Cafe. Therefore, you want to make sure they really show the best you.

Anyone, regardless of membership level, can see profiles pictures. The quality of yours might convince someone to get a paid account.

Christian Cafe is very accurate in terms of what it describes. This is a place for Christians, including Catholics, to assemble and find companionship. For those looking for faith-based dating, this is a great place to come to.

Gender Ratio Breakdown


Recommended Age

25-50

Number of Members

2 Million

Sign Up
Time

20 Minutes

For Singles Seeking

Serious Relationships

PROS

  • check
    Faith Based Founders
  • check
    "Prayer" Feature
  • check
    Informative Profiles

CONS

  • check
    Smaller User Base
  • check
    Can Only Upload         3 Photos

Editors Conclusion

Catholic singles can have an excellent online dating experience with each of these sites. Whether you use Match, Elite Singles, eHarmony, Catholic Singles, Catholic Match, or Christian Cafe, you can count on finding a place that cares about its users finding love.

What's equally as important is the care you put into your profile. Make sure you create a profile that shows the true you and gives people a reason to reach out to you, as well as messages that provide them with a reason to respond. Catholics like you understand that building relationships takes work, but it's worth it.

If you're wondering which sites we considered to be the best for Catholic dating, we would have to say
Catholic Match and Elite Singles. Catholic Match is the best choice for Catholic-specific dating, while Elite Singles is best for general dating, while also having lots of appeal for Catholics.

Take a look at Catholic Match and
Elite Singles to help determine which one would be best for your tastes. You might find that Catholic Match is better because of how it focuses on Catholicism specifically. 

However, Elite Singles may be a better option since you can search specifically for Catholics while also focusing on finding an educated partner. Whichever of the two sites you choose, you can look forward to a positive experience.

Click Here to Join Catholic Match